Pigfolio

PY184 Bismuth Vanadate Yellow

Bismuth vanadate.

18 tubes from 12 of 24 paint lines contain PY184. 12 are made from PY184 alone, which is the closest match when you're switching brands.

Toxicity
Handle with care Some makers put a safety label on it because of its vanadium content. Don't sand or spray it.
Drying
Medium
Opacity
Single-pigment tubes are mostly opaque.

About PY184

History

Bismuth vanadate yellow came into artists' paint in the later 20th century as a bright, opaque yellow without cadmium.

In mixes

A bright, clean, fairly opaque lemon. A common cadmium-free alternative, though usually weaker than cadmium.

Drying speed is typical for linseed oil; tubes ground in safflower or poppy oil, or with driers added, will differ. These are general notes on the pigment, not on any one brand.

Purest PY184, by brand

The best single-pigment PY184 tube from each line, ranked: artists' grade first, then lightfastness, then how firmly the pigment listing is confirmed. Ties are listed alphabetically.

  1. Williamsburg Bismuth Vanadate YellowSeries 7 · LF I · Opaque Opaque
  2. Blockx Lemon YellowSeries 6 · LF I · Opaque Opaque
  3. Cobra Permanent Lemon YellowLF I · Semi-opaque Semi-opaque
  4. Grumbacher Bismuth YellowSeries 4 · LF I · Semi-opaque Semi-opaque
  5. Langridge Bismuth VanadateSeries 3 · LF I · Opaque Opaque
  6. M. Graham Bismuth YellowSeries 6 · LF I · Opaque Opaque
  7. Rembrandt Permanent Yellow LemonSeries 3 · LF I · Semi-opaque Semi-opaque
  8. Schmincke Mussini Vanadium Yellow LightLF I · Opaque Opaque
  9. W&N Artists' Bismuth YellowSeries 4 · LF I · Opaque Opaque
  10. Holbein Bismuth YellowSeries C · LF I · Opaque Opaque
  11. Maimeri Puro Yellow VanadiumLF not rated

Not sold here by: Gamblin, Michael Harding, Old Holland, W&N Winton, Da Vinci, Van Gogh, Art Creation, Lukas 1862, W&N Griffin, Art Spectrum, Vasari, W&N Artisan.

Made from PY184 alone

Lemon YellowBlockx 212612PY184Series 6OpaqueLF IPermanent Lemon YellowCobra 254PY184Semi-opaqueLF IBismuth YellowGrumbacher P311PY184Series 4Semi-opaqueLF IBismuth YellowHolbein H264PY184Series COpaqueLF IBismuth VanadateLangridgePY184Series 3OpaqueLF IBismuth YellowM. Graham 019PY184Series 6OpaqueLF IYellow VanadiumMaimeri Puro 121PY184–Vanadium Yellow DeepSchmincke Mussini 10221PY184OpaqueLF IVanadium Yellow LightSchmincke Mussini 10220PY184OpaqueLF IPermanent Yellow LemonRembrandt 254PY184Series 3Semi-opaqueLF IBismuth Vanadate YellowWilliamsburg 6001929PY184Series 7OpaqueLF IBismuth YellowW&N Artists' 025PY184Series 4OpaqueLF I

PY184 with white added

Nickel Titanium Yellow LightRembrandt 279PW6PY184Series 2OpaqueLF I

Mixtures that contain PY184

ChartreuseCobra 233PY184PG7OpaqueLF IPrimary YellowCobra 275PY184PY154Semi-opaqueLF ICoeruleum HueGeorgian D111014113PW6PY184PB15:3Hue–Cobalt Green OpaqueSchmincke Mussini 10528PY184PG50OpaqueLF IViridianSchmincke Mussini 10529PW4PY184PG18Semi-opaqueLF I

Brands: Blockx, Cobra, Georgian, Grumbacher, Holbein, Langridge, M. Graham, Maimeri Puro, Schmincke Mussini, Rembrandt, Williamsburg, W&N Artists'.